Prosper is Going To Sue Deadbeat Borrowers

Prosper the p2p lending company is getting tough on late borrowers.

The “New Agency Test” is taking an interesting turn… Prosper is going to sue.  I just received the following email from Prosper.

The purpose of this email is to inform you of your right to choose what action you would like to take with regard to the accounts of the legal collection test currently underway.

Of the original 74 loans in the legal test, 68 remain (6 loans have fallen out due to such things as curing or bankruptcy filings). In order to present the strongest case, our law firm believes that it is best for Prosper to be the official owner of the loan when suit is filed. As such, we have developed the following process to accomplish this:

You currently hold promissory notes on 6 loan(s) in the test group (loan numbers comprising the test group listed in Exhibit 1). As of January 15th, 2008, the total Gross Amount Due to you on these loans is $325.26. If the loans had been sold in the December debt sale, they would have brought you $33.11 in proceeds.

The total of the 68 loans has a gross amount due of $735,709.66 and would have sold for $73,506.03. Additional loans may be removed from the pool, for such reasons as curing or declaring bankruptcy prior to 1/23/08 – the projected pool creation date.

You may choose to accept the $33.11 (the “debt sale amount”) for your loans now or to receive a pro-rata share of the net recoveries of this legal test pool. The pro-rata share would be based on the gross amount due on your Notes divided by the gross amount due to all lenders who choose to be in the test, calculated as of January 23, 2008 (the “Pool Commencement Date”), i.e., the date after which lenders must respond to this notification indicate whether they wish to participate in the test on a pro-rata basis. Based on the gross amounts due as of $325.26 if all lenders chose to remain in the test, your share would be 4.4211%.

The above share percentage is based on the 68 loans currently identified. Loans could be removed from the pool (due to cure payments, bankruptcies, etc.) prior to the Pool Commencement Date, in which case your percentage may be higher or lower.

The costs that will need to be recovered are: the purchase price that Prosper pays for the loan portions of lenders who do not want to continue with the test, court and service of process costs and the attorney firm’s contingency fee (which is 24%).

If you choose to accept your pro-rata share of the net recoveries of the legal test pool, net recoveries (if any) will be credited to your account monthly, for as long as there are loans remaining in legal collection. Due to the unpredictability of litigation, we do not know how long the test will take before legal collection efforts and activities are concluded on all loans in the test; however, we estimate that the test could continue for up to 18 to 24 months.

Since this is a test, we have not yet designed the system to track these revenues within the normal statement process. As such, the loans will be defaulted at zero value and the accounting provided on a monthly basis in a supplementary statement.

Please reply to this email by placing an “X” in the box below that signifies your choice on or before Tuesday 01/22/08. If we do not receive your reply by that date, we will assume that you do NOT wish to participate in this test. As such, we will transfer $33.11 into your account.

If you choose to participate in the test, we will send you a statement confirming your pro-rata share once the responses are tallied and final loan composition is set.

IF YOU CHOOSE TO ACCEPT YOUR PRO-RATA SHARE OF THE NET RECOVERIES OF THE LEGAL TEST POOL, THERE IS NO GUARANTEE THAT YOU WILL RECEIVE AN AMOUNT EQUAL TO OR GREATER THAN THE DEBT SALE AMOUNT, AND THERE IS NO GUARANTEE THAT YOU WILL RECEIVE ANY AMOUNT AT ALL. This is because legal costs and fees are deducted from recoveries before amounts are distributed to lenders, and therefore if costs and fees exceed recoveries, there will be nothing left to distribute to the lenders. If costs and fees exceed recoveries, you will not, however, have to make any out-of-pocket payments to make up the difference.

This test is designed to determine whether the viable threat of legal consequences will improve the repayment statistics for Prosper loans. This test is an important step in creating that awareness of consequences. Please consider your choice carefully.

Prosper Marketplace, Inc.

Please reply to this email by placing an X in one of the following:

[ ] I do NOT wish to participate in this test. In exchange for a purchase price of $33.11, I assign all promissory notes currently held by me associated with the loans listed in Exhibit 1 to Prosper Marketplace, Inc.

[ ] I wish to participate in this test. In exchange for a pro-rata share of at least 4.4211% of the future net recoveries of this test, I assign all promissory notes currently held by me associated with the loans listed in Exhibit 1 to Prosper Marketplace, Inc.

You must reply to this email by on or before Tuesday 01/22/08. If we do not receive your reply by that date, we will assume that you do NOT wish to participate in this test. Thank you.

Exhibit One: Loans Currently In Legal Test Pool


LoanID

LoanID

LoanID

LoanId

848

3918

6127

7739

950

3992

6302

7779

1840

4001

6311

8068

1850

4371

6383

8167

1906

4389

6759

8204

1975

4539

6809

9392

1984

4620

6880

9471

2297

4720

7008

9544

2407

4764

7186

12474

2576

4875

7250

12577

2627

5092

7270

12748

2854

5350

7348

12876

2982

5370

7385

13632

3059

5420

7458

13650

3069

5555

7501

14577

3584

5923

7627

14865

3897

6069

7673

16136

Thank you,

Prosper Operations

Blog Traffic Exchange Related Posts
  • blog traffic exchangeProsper People-to-People Lending Market Survey San Francisco – October 9, 2007 – Prosper (www.prosper.com), America’s largest people-to-people lending marketplace, today released its September People-to-People Lending Market Survey.  Prosper’s People-to-People Lending Market Survey provides key statistics and a market commentary by Chris Larsen, Chief Executive Officer and Co-Founder of Prosper.   Prosper’s People-to-People Lending Market Survey......
  • blog traffic exchangeProsper's People-to-People Lending Market Survey SAN FRANCISCO--(BUSINESS WIRE)--Prosper (www.prosper.com), America's largest people-to-people lending marketplace, today introduced its first monthly People-to-People Lending Market Survey. Prosper's People-to-People Lending Market Survey will survey the marketplace each month to provide key statistics including: membership and loan volume statistics; marketplace returns; borrower rates; mix of prime, near prime and sub-prime......
  • blog traffic exchangeIn Defense of Living Off Dividends Living Off Dividends (aka WealthBuildingLessons (WAB) on Prosper) wrote a guest post on the Prosper Blog: Why I Love Prosper.com. The blog post has generated some heated comments due to one aspect of the post. WAB claimed "over 13% annualized returns". When questioned what his calculation actually was he said.........
  • blog traffic exchangeProsper Referral Program -- About Time Ok I admit it.  I have whored out my blog via the Prosper referral program today. I was not paid to do so in anyway except hopefully in referrals.  I felt that this step by Prosper is exactly what the marketplace needed to grow organically and virally.  Therefore, I decide that today was......
  • blog traffic exchangeNovember 2007 Prosper Marketplace Survey with Commentary from Kirk Inglis CFO November 2007 Prosper People-to-People Lending Market Survey Membership and Loan Volume Statistics --------------------------------------------- 2007 2006 November November Year-to- Year-to- Since 2007 2006 Date Date Inception ---------------------------------------------------------------------- New Members 33,917 19,062 368,741 119,294 506,508 ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Funded Loans $6.4 $3.3 $74.9 $23.9 $103.3 million million million million million ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Average Loan Size......
Blog Traffic Exchange Related Websites
  • blog traffic exchangeProsper.com Review: A Review of the Prosper Marketplace Prosper.com, also called Prosper Marketplace, is a service that is part of the emerging peer-to-peer lending industry which facilitates the lending and borrowing of money between its users. How it Works: Prosper, Lending Club, Zopa and other firms around the world are sidestepping the banking industry by creating an......
  • timemoneySave Time, Money and Space in Over 80 Ways If you're looking for handy gadgets, tools and various items that can save you time, money or space (or all three!) this list of more than 80 top products is just what you need. Everyone's got saving money on their minds these days. Some of us are always looking to......
  • Free LoanPayday Loans and the Misfits Rebels are people too and sometimes they need fast cash. Too bad we are not talking about rebels, rather we are talking about fees that come along with payday loans and how they misfit our lives. Practically all and sundry are consider payday loans, especially when times are hard. The......
  • flowerMaking Extra Money With P2P Lending Peer to Peer lending is quickly becoming one of the hottest new ways to create multiple streams of income. While there is risk involved, there are various methods that can reduce the risks that individual investors face and provide protection against non-payments. If you're looking for an potential way to......
  • blog traffic exchangeProsper.com Review: A Review of the Prosper Marketplace Prosper.com, also called Prosper Marketplace, is a service that is part of the emerging peer-to-peer lending industry which facilitates the lending and borrowing of money between its users. How it Works: Prosper, Lending Club, Zopa and other firms around the world are sidestepping the banking industry by creating an alternative......
Online Stores If you liked this article, vote for it on del.icio.us and stumbleupon.


Categories:

Collections, Prosper.com



13 comments ↓
#1 Mike on 01.16.08 at 7:18 am

This is indeed most interesting. First, Prosper is getting aggressive on collections and actually doing something. Second, they’re PROACTIVELY contacting their lenders about it. Color me stunned.

#2 » Update to Prosper Lawsuit Notice on 01.16.08 at 6:43 pm

[...] want to subscribe to my RSS feed or via email. Thanks for visiting!There was a math error in the original letter.  My correct maximum portion of the loan pool is 0.044211% not the previously stated [...]

#3 Personal Loan Portfolio on 01.16.08 at 8:24 pm

It is highly likely that the default rate is so high (er, sorry — the late rate) because borrowers have no fear of Prosper. I think Prosper may have not initially wanted to sue to try to ignore the issue for publicity reasons and because they have little to gain directly from the recovery of the loan. However, with nearly 20% of loans running late across credit grades after several months time, they had to do something.

By the way, click on the play list on the video (second button from the right) at Stomper Blog Going Natural http://www.stompernet.net/gn2/ Select the second video from the top (you have to scroll up) about Duplicate Content. These guys say off-site duplicate content does not matter. On-site duplicate content is what they say kills a website. To Google, this page and the update page are likely to look identical.

#4 Personal Loan Portfolio on 01.16.08 at 8:26 pm

By the way, I have been wondering why you have the “You Comment, I follow” logo on your web page. Your site uses the nofollow attribute in comments.

#5 Kevin on 01.16.08 at 8:36 pm

The trackbacks are nofollowed, but any comment older than 3 days is supposed to remove the no follow. (that is to gives me time to review the links in case they make it past spam karma and point to a bad neighborhood.

I altered the 2nd post after watching the video. Thanks!

#6 Personal Loan Portfolio on 01.16.08 at 9:14 pm

Those guys do an awesome job explaining search engine stuff, but they do an even better job of selling their best stuff to people who are interested in it. I heard stompernet made 60 million in one year by charging subscriptions. Although, they did spend some bucks hiring good people to drive great research for their members.

Thanks for answering the question. I did not notice the nofollows were removed after time. That is an interesting idea to deal with the spam. Personally, I turned on moderation because I don’t want any links to unmentionable things to appear on my site ever, but there are days that someone may post a comment and it takes me 10 hours to approve it which I know hurts the discussion. Of my regular commenters, I think that you are the only one who now requires approval and I can’t figure out how to get you past akismet automatically.

By the way, I just watched your video a few posts back. That was a good presentation by all th participants. It was really funny when you showed the borrower picture and your wife’s comments.

#7 Little Troll on 01.21.08 at 7:24 am

“Don’t Sue Me Bro!”

#8 » Accounting for the New Agency Test in Quicken on 01.25.08 at 5:12 am

[...] it was revealed that Prosper is Going To Sue Deadbeat Borrowers and that lenders on the loans would be given a choice between taking a guaranteed upfront buyout [...]

#9 Chrisfs on 01.25.08 at 11:36 am

Go away on vacation for 10 days and things change.
Hmm, this would be a big temptation. As I posted a couple times in the old forums when this came up, I would take the money now, because the length and cost of lawsuits are potentially too big, but I would want to see how it turned out.
Go You!, for being the canary on the coal mine.

#10 » RateLadder IRR/ROI 3/08 Update — (2.11%) to 13.06% on 03.03.08 at 8:34 am

[...] This month had a major event that I think will make it hard for the various ROI sites to even track accruately anymore… The “New Agency Test” aka Prosper is suing borrowers. [...]

#11 In Defense of Living Off Dividends : Rate Ladder on 03.27.08 at 7:35 am

[...] values for these figures range from (2.11%) to 13.06%. In addition, I have 6 loans in the new agency test. I have very little hope of someone without access to my account transaction history being able to [...]

#12 Doug Fuller Update Legal Test : Rate Ladder on 05.09.08 at 8:18 pm

[...] New Agency Test aka Legal Test has been updated via the blog: Legal Test Update We have obtained service on 12 of the suits – and [...]

#13 Prosper Update Enhances the Legal Enforceability of Promissory Notes | P2P Lending, Peer to Peer Lending, People to People Lending | News, Information, Borrowing and Lending Strategy on 06.24.08 at 8:35 am

[...] bold part caught my attention as I am on the loans that are part of the legal test.  Related or just coincidental use of the root legal?  More info [...]

Leave a Comment

aa algorithm axis azerbaijan banks benefit blog borrowers ceo Collections credit grade credit history credit information credit score curves doug fuller email friends and family good luck google income borrowers interest rate interest rates investments launch lenders lending institutions liquidity loans marketplace money mozambique peer to peer lending portfolio plan private data promissory notes quiet period registration statement risk securities and exchange securities and exchange commission spreadsheets sql student loans Zopa