WealthBoy and Minimum P2P Loan Diversification

WealthBoy is new on the scene and assuming he keeps posting I think he will make a welcome addition to the Prosper community.

A couple of days ago, he wrote a guest post for the Prosper Blog: Diversification and Setting Limits.

In it, he talks about diversification and the MINIMUM number of loans required to be adequately diversified — 30!

Why 30? A well-known statistical rule of thumb states that you should try to use a sample size of at least 30 in order to improve the accuracy of any analysis performed on normally distributed data. According to the central limit theorem, “as the sample size n increases, the distribution of the sample average approaches the normal distribution with a mean µ and variance σ2/n irrespective of the shape of the original distribution.” That means that even if data is not normally distributed, as the sample size increases the distribution will approximate that of the normal distribution.

It is very likely that the average return for unsecured loans is normally distributed, so the rule of 30 should apply well to peer-to-peer lending. Even if the average return isn’t normally distributed, the central limit theorem states, that the larger the sample size is the better it will approximate the normal distribution anyway. This means that the more loans in which you invest (with equal amounts per investment), the better your chances are in achieving the average expected return.

30 * $50 = $1,500 (not an insignificant sum).  Personally, I think right number is no more than 2% of your portfolio in any one loan. $50 / 2% = $2,500 or 50 $50 loans.

None of this is to say, “You have to put in this much money,” you could put in less.  The fewer loans that you make the more random chance will come into play.  If you make 1 $50 your loan will either pay to completion or default and you are betting your Prosper experience on the outcome.  If you make 30 or more loans you are a statistical lock (2 standard deviations) to have your expected return match the marketplace for similar loans.

The out clause — similar loans.  Don’t invest in HR, E, or even D without doing your homework.  In fact, don’t invest in any loans without doing your homework.  (Homework is to use and understand this tool: Marketplace Performance Tool) Extended credit comes into play and you should have a firm grasp of the marketplace before manually bidding.  Not interested in understanding the marketplace? Luckily, Prosper has made it easy to invest and proper diversify with Portfolio plans. 

Regardless of your choice of bidding methods (manual, standing orders, or portfolio plans) I encourage you to properly diversify.  Listen to WealthBoy and invest in at least 30 loans or better yet listen to RateLadder and invest in at least 50 loans. 

If you are interested in trying Prosper I encourage you sign up via this link: New Lenders Receive $25 Activation Bonus.

Business & Personal Loans. Great Rates. Prosper.

Blog Traffic Exchange Related Posts
  • RateLadder.com LoanNew Loan Funded — payoff current loan and new invest on business — $25,000 at 29.00% — E Credit — DTI 37% My very first E credit loan... A new loan funded (payoff current loan and new invest on business — $25,000 at 29.00%).  I participated via a manual bid (lured by the excellent extended credit and interest rate?).  The borrow had E credit and 37% DTI.  As a reminder my standing orders only......
  • Prosper Lending Review -- 11 perspectives on p2p lending Prosper Lending review has an excellent new article. It combines 11 responses (including both Lending Club, Prosper, and yours truly) to a reader's question.  It is well done on all front's.  Here is the question asked: Reader's Question: I am in my mid-30's. I am not rich, but I am......
  • Prosper's People-to-People Lending Market Survey SAN FRANCISCO--(BUSINESS WIRE)--Prosper (www.prosper.com), America's largest people-to-people lending marketplace, today introduced its first monthly People-to-People Lending Market Survey. Prosper's People-to-People Lending Market Survey will survey the marketplace each month to provide key statistics including: membership and loan volume statistics; marketplace returns; borrower rates; mix of prime, near prime and sub-prime......
  • pninen in Prosper forums -- Magnificent Writeup on the Lender Costs of Not Paying Interest Here is the post in it's entirety because it is that good: In the early days of Prosper, I estimated that the cost of my idle cash (cash balance waiting to be bid, cash tied up in bids, cash tied up in loan verification, cash tied up waiting for payments......
  • Prosper is outperforming the 2-year return on the S&P 500Prosper Returns Beat S&P 500 I received an email last night from Prosper claiming that "Prosper Beat the S&P 500" Did you know that the average loan on Prosper is outperforming the 2-year return on the S&P 500? Smart lenders like you have already discovered that lending on Prosper is a great way to earn......
Blog Traffic Exchange Related Websites
  • Your Home as an Investment? Let's Re-think this. Mr. ToughMoneyLove engages in many debates over "good" and "bad" debt and the logic of having substantial equity in your home or even paying off your mortgage.  Regarding the latter, some folks insist that their home is an investment and resist building equity through their own efforts (such as making a......
  • Ipod Touch Information? Here Is iPod Touch Information The iPod Touch is a portable media player and Wi-Fi mobile platform designed and marketed by Apple Co. The product was launched on September 5, 2007 through an event called The Beat Goes On.[1] The iPod Touch adds the multi-touch graphical user interface to the......
  • Standardbild wenn Produktbild nicht vorhanden Wenn Sie ein Standardbild verwenden möchten, wenn Sie kein Artikel zum Artikel haben so öffnen Sie [catalog/]includes/function/html_output.php und ab Zeile 73 - 113 folgenden Code suchen : // The HTML image wrapper function function tep_image($src, $alt = '', $width = '', $height = '', $parameters = '') { if (......
  • When Are Your Funds Average Returns Good Enough? This month's column by James B. Stewart in SmartMoney magazine is about "enhanced mutual funds"; ones that have avowed to beat the market. They are index funds of their own making, rather than ones that follow a certain index. That sounds like regular old investing to me, doesn't it?......
  • $1 million goal$1 Million by 2017. What's Your Financial Goal? Before I started this blog, I did not really have a good financial goal. Actually, my financial goal was similar to 99.9% of other Americans...I wanted to be rich. But what is rich? In "Are you wealthy? Here's a test," I defined wealthy as: "...when income from my assets can......
If you liked this article, vote for it on del.icio.us and stumbleupon.


Categories:

Prosper.com, Strategy



8 comments ↓
#1 onthefence on 01.10.08 at 3:26 pm

Most people end up diversifying up to 30 over time any way.

#2 Tom on 01.10.08 at 6:15 pm

Matt wrote a good article about diversification. He found that 70% of lenders have less than 20 loans.

#3 Personal Loan Portfolio on 01.10.08 at 8:40 pm

Good points about diversification. A few hundred dollars across several loans is not enough. A person will either achieve an outstanding return or a terrible return without investing in 30-50 loans like you recommend.

By the way, since Lending Club allows $25 loans, a lender can have double the diversification on the same amount of money. So to spread you money across 60 loans only takes $1,250. That is one of the reasons that I started lending with LC instead of Prosper.

#4 Prosper Roundup — Prosper Blog Gets a Page Rank Edition on 01.20.08 at 12:40 pm

[...] RateLadder reacts to WealthBoy and Minimum P2P Loan Diversification [...]

#5 6 Ways To Manage The Risk of Peer to Peer Lending on 02.05.08 at 5:10 am

[...] the recommended MINIMUM number of loans to have in your lending portfolio has been deemed to be between 30 and 50 loans. So spread your money around when you start the process, and again, see if a site offers a way to [...]

#6 Prosper Lending Review — 11 perspectives on p2p lending : Rate Ladder on 03.18.08 at 7:20 am

[...] results (or even significant past results) are lacking… Proceed with caution, fully diversify (I think at least 50 loans), and have fun, but don’t bet the [...]

#7 Lending Club, Prosper.com, and more: P2P Lending News Roundup | Personal Loan Portfolio on 04.10.08 at 7:55 am

[...] to try P2P lending, please invest across more loans. See the articles at Prosper Lending Review and Rate Ladder on the subject of P2P loan [...]

#8 Making Extra Money With P2P Lending | Rich Credit Debt Loan on 06.25.08 at 5:51 am

[...] After the loan opportunity has been posted, lenders or investors will browse through and see if they want to take that risk. Most of the current P2P sites allow sharing of loans so that the risk is spread around. For example, if someone needs a $9000 loan, instead of one lender offering the whole amount, thirty lenders may each provide $300. The interest rate payments will be equally divided among those lenders based on much of the loan they purchase.  As with everything make sure you diversify, ideally you would want AT LEAST 30-50 separate loans. [...]

Leave a Comment

Email Updates