Yesterday a reader posted the following comment…
You rely a lot on DTI – Is DTI a good predictor of default? For the last year, 100 days, or what? Also, what about very high DTI’s (eg >1000%, usually means the person hasn’t been able to verify income) — are they safer than DTIs around 80-100%?
Here is my response…
So far DTI is not correlated to late payments. However, because it weighs so heavily in normal loan applications I think it would be foolish on my part to ignore it. Other lenders seem to agree as rates for higher DTI values are higher.
An unverifiable DTI in my mind is no better than any loan of the same credit and extended credit. It might be argued that it is worse.
The journey continues and some day we may be able to answer your question with confidence and clarity, but for now, this early in the game, I will just wave my hands at it.
I am interested in reader option… What do you guys think?
Related Posts -
2 New Loans (Part 1/2) -- CCSJ Marketing Acquisition & Expansion -- $20,000 at 15.65% -- C Credit -- DTI 14% A new loan funded this afternoon (CCSJ Marketing Acquisition & Expansion  (Loan #6383) â $20,000 at 15.65%). I participated via my standing order: Low DTI -- AF. Which is this loan was funded as a low debt to income ratio and was an auto-funding loan. The borrow had C...... -
State Rate Caps Force Borrower (Blogger) To Take Action A C credit (super clean) borrower from Virgina (rate capped at 11%) has been trying to get a loan unsuccessfully on Prosper. Here is the description: Purpose of loan: Replace an air conditioning unit that went out during a 100 degree day in the Washington DC area. I have made...... -
Prosper Estimated Return Guidance Pessimistic Example -- aka PML #5 -- Pay off high interest home improvement cards In my Friday post, I encouraged everyone to think for themselves when it comes to estimated return guidance. It is after all only an estimate. Today, I would like to pimp a listing I have bid on that I feel demonstrates a great return loan, but it is a fairly...... -
New Loan Funded — Too Much Business / Need to Expand — $9,500 at 20% — AA Credit — DTI 45% A new loan funded (Too Much Business / Need to Expand â $9,500 at 20%). I participated via a 2 standing orders (Low Amt Extreme DTI and Low Amt Any DTI) and a manual bid the loan was Autofunding. The borrower had AA credit and 45% DTI. As a reminder my standing orders...... -
RateLadder IRR/ROI 5/08 Update -- (1.35%) to 15.3% Well another month down... Nothing major happened that would effect my IRR/ROI (like a debt sale.) It was a fairly uneventful month for my Prosper p2p lending account, but it was a good month... My ROI/IRR is higher on 4/5 of my tracking indices (it will be 5/6 when the......
Related Websites - The $29 fee that cost Bank of America so much more … I once had a credit card through MBNA. I loved this card. It was an alumni card that proudly displayed my alma mater.Then, Bank of America bought MBNA. Suddenly, things got bad. The web site functions no longer worked like they should. In particular, paying the card online became much......
- My rate went up WHY?! This MSN Money article, Why your credit card rate just went up reports on an increasingly-common practice of credit-card issuers. They'll raise your rate even without a late payment on their card! Just make a late payment somewhere else -- that's all it takes for some issuers to hike your......
-
Getting Out of Debt Quickly pt 4 This is part 4 of a 4 part series on getting out of debt quickly. Make sure that you read all four parts in order to get the most out of this sequence of hints on getting yourself or your family out of the debt trap. If lenders happen to...... - Late night TV and debt reduction I have essentially the equivalent of expanded cable in my hotel room out on the West Coast. This is more than we have at home. I don't miss it, but cop shows can be entertaining. ;)A majority of the ads this late at night (the ones that weren't for performance......
-
Citi CashReturns Card Review: Good Rewards Card If you use a credit card on a regular basis, you’ll probably appreciate the benefits of a rewards card. Although many such cards abound, sometimes it’s hard to find one that makes it easy for you to enjoy its perks and benefits. One interesting card that you may want......
- 19.2 volt & Higher Cordless Drills Power Tools Tools Home Improvement
- Journey Into Mystery Superhero Silver Age (1956-69) Comics Collectibles
- SPF 25 and Higher Sunscreen Sun Care Skin Care Store
- Journey J Rock, Pop Music Memorabilia Entertainment Memorabilia
- Late Summer Perennials Flower Seeds Plants, Seeds & Bulbs Gardening & Plants Yard, Garden & Outdoor Living Nursery
Categories:
Prosper.com, Strategy
Tags:
5 comments ↓
I think that the current lack of correlation between DTI and late payments is due to the strength of the US economy over the past couple of years. Once a recession sets in, I predict that the high DTI loans will tend to be later than low DTI loans.
I think I agree.
I also think that DTI might be a differentiator later in the loan cycle… Still early.
Ok, I pulled the download from couple days ago, and looked at all loans 12 months or older, with a DTI reported. 287 “good” (current, paid, or repurchased) vs 51 “bad” (late or default, I left out the 5 labelled “cancelled” because I don’t know if that means a lender got screwed or what). Assuming variances are equal, t-test shows no significant difference in the DTIs. This means, out of all the “aged” loans, there’s a 95% certainty that the DTI of the perfect payers was not lower than the DTI of the non-perfect payers. more to follow
ok. So far I am not out on a limb
I think you should take out repurchased too. Those loans were bought back by prosper because of fraud. They have a 100% fraud guarantee.
Ok, I had to look up some old statistics lessons; I made a mistake in using a test that assumes the DTIs were normally distributed. Actually log(DTI) are normally distributed, so I re-did the comparisons based on log(DTI), again with loans 12 months or older. 282 perfect loans are paid or current, mean(ie average) DTI 0.1249. 51 bad loans are late or defaulted, mean DTI .1356. 40 very bad loans are 3+ months late or defaulted, mean DTI .1404. 22 defaulted loans have a mean DTI .1393. You can see the averages are different, but the difference is not statistically significant. That is, I can’t say with 95% certainty that defaulters (or any other group of non-perfect borrowers) have a different DTI than perfect borrowers. Among every group, from perfect to defaulted borrowers, there is a huge spread, from almost zero, to over 50% DTI. Also notice that the average in every category is well below .15, a number that seems pretty safe… This is not even addressing the “good” borrowers who have DTI of a zillion because they can’t verify income.
Leave a Comment